Sunday, February 6, 2022

Amazon Bags are Not Recyclable: LDPE Resin Code 4

Plastic pollution is everywhere, and you know it when you see it, but you probably can’t explain the difference between types. And which types are recyclable and which types end up in the ocean or a landfill? 

Follow Phillip
Amazon has been increasingly sending packages wrapped in a thick white plastic bag with their black arrow logos. The bags are marked with the resin code "4." Resin code "4" items are generally not recyclable in the United States. If they go anywhere for recycling they are shipped to 3rd world countries in Asia or Africa where they can end up dumped into the ocean or on land illegally.

The Amazon bags boast that the packaging is lighter but say nothing about what to do with it after the fact.  They do point consumers to a website:  amazon.com/thispackaging which touts all the ways Amazon is doing better with packaging but doesn't mention these bags.
So we looked into it.  Amazon bags display the resin code "4" indicating that they are LDPE (Low density polyethylene) which technically could be recycled but practically is not recyclable in the USA.  Plastic bags, like grocery bags made from LDPE, have a tendency to tangle in recycling machinery.  LDPE plastics require too much time to be economically viable recyclables in the USA so ultimately, these plastics are dumped in landfills or shipped offshore to Asia or Africa.

China quit accepting plastics in 2017 as part of their National Sword Policy which effectively banned all plastic imports, and effectively eliminated any market for these plastic bags to be recycled.  The last year for which data is readily available (2015) the EPA found that only 6.2% of LDPE generated that year was recycled.

The Yacht that Amazon Built
Jeff Bezos' Superyacht "Y721" cost $485 million to construct.

We know Amazon can do better.  Jeff Bezos has figured a way to get his new €430,000,000 ($485,000,000), 417-foot superyacht out of Rotterdam (by dismantling bridges and reassembling them) so we think he could figure a way to ship Amazon purchases in something that isn't going to end up polluting the environment for eons.

A typical plastic grocery bag takes up to 30 years to degrade in the natural environment.  Amazon's bags are not typical, they are thicker and heavier.  A best guess for their biodegradability?  Maybe 150 years.
Publix Supermarket bags display the resin code "2" for High Density Polyethylene and they, like Amazon bags, are technically recyclable, but rarely are they recycled.  Instead they litter the environment, clog drain pipes, fill landfills, and yet they are not the most important reason not to shop at Publix.  The most important reason not to shop at Publix is Julie Fancelli.


Plastic remains the most complicated material to recycle, in part because consumers don’t know what types can be disposed of and in which ways.  Simply put you may be able to recycle resin code "1" or "2" plastics in some localities in USA but most of it will be shipped offshore or sent to a landfill.

Resin codes "3, 4, 5, 6, and 7" are generally NOT recyclable.
Image Creator: Romolo Tavani

Plastic Resin Codes
A product made of plastic is often stamped with a resin code, which is a number between one and seven inside a small triangle made of arrows. The presence of a resin code doesn’t necessarily mean that the product can be recycled. It’s the number inside the triangle that counts, because each number corresponds to a different type of plastic.

1: PET or PETE (Polyethylene terephthalate)

There’s a good chance you’ve held something made of this plastic type today. PET or PETE is what’s used to make bottles for soda, water and other drinks. It’s also used to make cooking oil containers, plastic peanut butter jars and containers for other popular food items.

PET/PETE products CAN be recycled but are primarily shipped offshore.

2: HDPE (High density polyethylene)

HDPE plastics are also extremely common. They’re those used to make milk jugs, shampoo bottles, cleaning product containers and detergent bottles.

HDPE products CAN be recycled but are primarily shipped offshore.

3: PVC (Polyvinyl chloride)

PVC is a soft, flexible plastic, so it’s used for a huge array of household products. Plastic tubing, kids’ toys, plastic trays and furniture are often made out of PVC.

PVC products CANNOT be recycled.

4: LDPE (Low density polyethylene)

A lot of plastic wrappings are made of LDPE plastic. It’s also used to make grocery bags and the bags that hold newspapers, sliced bread loaves and fresh produce, among other things.

LDPE products CAN SOMETIMES be recycled but in practice are NOT RECYCLABLE.

5: PP (Polypropylene)

PP is used to make the food containers used for products like yogurt, sour cream and margarine. It’s also made into straws, rope, carpet and bottle caps.

PP products CAN SOMETIMES be recycled but in practice are NOT RECYCLABLE.

6: PS (Polystyrene)

Styrofoam products are made out of PS plastic, so it’s commonly used to make disposable coffee cups, packing peanuts, coolers and to-go food containers.

PS products CAN SOMETIMES be recycled but in practice are NOT RECYCLABLE..

7: Other

Any type of plastic that doesn’t fit into one of the first six categories falls under this heading. Products stamped with a 7 are often made out of multiple plastic types or out of other types of plastic that cannot easily be recycled.

#7 products CANNOT be easily recycled.  In practice these products are NOT recycled.

Finally
Just because a plastic type can be recycled doesn’t mean your local municipality wants you to put it into your recycling bin for collection. It’s not viable for some plastics recycling companies to take hard-to-process plastic products like Styrofoam. Bags made of type 4 plastic, like produce and grocery bags, also shouldn’t be put into recycling bins because they can get tangled in the equipment at recycling facilities. Grocery stores collect these bags for proper plastics recycling.

So what does all of that mean for you? 

Types 1 and 2 plastics may be tossed into standard recycling bins.

Other plastic types may not be permitted in your bin, depending on your location, and are generally discarded.

All plastics are regularly shipped offshore.  Read more about the burgeoning plastics trade in Senegal (the world's latest dump for plastics) below:

‘Everyone’s Looking for Plastic.’ As Waste Rises, So Does Recycling.

Plagued by plastic pollution, Senegal wants to replace pickers at the garbage dump with a formal recycling system that takes advantage of the new market for plastics.



DAKAR, Senegal — A crowd of people holding curved metal spikes jumped on trash spilling out of a dump truck in Senegal’s biggest landfill, hacking at the garbage to find valuable plastic.

Nearby, sleeves rolled up, suds up to their elbows, women washed plastic jerrycans in rainbow colors, cut into pieces. Around them, piles of broken toys, plastic mayonnaise jars and hundreds of discarded synthetic wigs stretched as far as the eye could see, all ready to be sold and recycled.

Plastic waste is exploding in Senegal, as in many countries, as populations and incomes grow and with them, demand for packaged, mass-produced products.

This has given rise to a growing industry built around recycling plastic waste, by businesses and citizens alike. From Chinese traders to furniture makers and avant-garde fashion designers, many in Senegal make use of the constant stream of plastic waste.


Garbage trucks entering the massive Mbeubeuss landfill in Dakar, which the government plans to close and replace with smaller sorting centers.

Mbeubeuss — the dump site serving Senegal’s seaside capital of Dakar — is where it all begins. More than 2,000 trash pickers, as well as scrubbers, choppers, haulers on horse-drawn carts, middlemen and wholesalers make a living by finding, preparing and transporting the waste for recycling. It adds up to a huge informal economy that supports thousands of families.

Over more than 50 years at the dump, Pape Ndiaye, the doyen of waste pickers, has watched the community that lives off the dump grow, and seen them turn to plastic — a material that 20 years ago the pickers considered worthless.

“We’re the people protecting the environment,” said Mr. Ndiaye, 76, looking out at the plastic scattered over Gouye Gui, his corner of the dump. “Everything that pollutes it, we take to industries, and they transform it.”

Despite all of the efforts to recycle, much of Senegal’s waste never makes it to landfills, instead littering the landscape. Knockoff Adidas sandals and containers that once held a local version of Nutella block drains. Thin plastic bags that once contained drinking water meander back and forth in the Senegalese surf, like jellyfish. Plastic shopping bags burn in residential neighborhoods, sending clouds of chemical-smelling smoke into the hazy air.

Senegal is just one of many countries trying to clean up, formalize the waste disposal system and embrace recycling on a bigger scale. By 2023, the African Union says, the goal is that 50 percent of the waste used in African cities should be recycled.

But this means that Senegal also has to grapple with the informal system that has grown up over decades, of which the grand dump at Mbeubeuss (pronounced Mm-beh-BEHSE) is a major part.

The recycled plastic makes it to enterprises of all stripes across Senegal, which has one of the most robust economies in West Africa.

At a factory in Thies, an inland city known for its tapestry industry to the east of Dakar, recycled plastic pellets are spun out into long skeins, which are then woven into the colorful plastic mats used in almost every Senegalese household.

Custom-made mats from this factory lined the catwalk at Dakar Fashion Week in December, focused this time on sustainability and held in a baobab forest. Signs were constructed out of old water bottles. Tables and chairs were made of melted down plastic.

The trend has changed the focus of the waste pickers who have worked the dump for decades, gleaning anything of value.

“Now everyone’s looking for plastic,” said Mouhamadou Wade, 50, smiling broadly as he brewed a pot of sweet, minty tea outside his sorting shack in Mbeubeuss, where he has been a waste picker for over 20 years.

Adja Seyni Diop, sitting on a wooden bench by the shack in the kind of long, elegant dress favored by Senegalese women, agreed.

When she first began waste picking, at age 11 in 1998, nobody was interested in buying plastic, she said, so she left it in the trash heap, collecting only scrap metal. But these days, plastic is by far the easiest thing to sell to middlemen and traders. She supports her family on the income she makes there, between $25 and $35 a week.

Mr. Wade and Ms. Diop work together at Bokk Jom, a kind of informal union representing over half of Mbeubeuss’s waste pickers. And most of them spend their days searching for plastic.

A few days later, I bumped into Ms. Diop in her workplace — a towering platform made entirely of rancid waste that is so hostile an environment that it is known as “Yemen.” I almost didn’t recognize her, with her face obscured by bandannas, two hats and sunglasses, to protect her against the particles of trash blowing in every direction.

Around us, herds of white, long-horned cattle munched on garbage as dozens of pickers descended on each dump truck emptying its load. Some young men even hung from the tops of trucks to catch precious plastic as it spilled out of the trucks, before bulldozers came to sweep what remained to the edge of the trash mountain.

Most of the pickers who target plastic, like Ms. Diop, sell it, at about 13 cents a kilogram, to two Chinese plastic merchants who have depots on the landfill site. The merchants process it into pellets and ship it to China to be made into new goods, said Abdou Dieng, the manager of Mbeubeuss, who works for Senegal’s growing waste management agency and has brought a little order to the chaos of the landfill.

Senegal is flooded with other countries’ plastic waste as well as its own.

China stopped accepting the world’s unprocessed plastic waste in 2018. Casting around for new countries to export it to, the U.S. began to ship plastic to other countries, including Senegal.

But that is beginning to change, too, as the Senegalese government appears to be cracking down on plastic waste coming from abroad. Last year, a German company was fined $3.4 million when one of its ships was caught trying to smuggle 25 tons of plastic waste into Senegal.

In the past two years, the number of trucks coming to Mbeubeuss daily has increased from 300 to 500.

But the government says that in a few years, the giant landfill will close, replaced by much smaller sorting and composting centers as part of a joint project with the World Bank.

Then, most of the money made from plastic waste will go into government coffers. The waste pickers worry about their livelihoods.

Mr. Ndiaye, the last of the original waste pickers who came to Mbeubeuss in 1970, surveyed what has been his workplace for the past half-century. He remembered the large baobab under which he used to take tea breaks, now long dead, replaced by piles of plastic.

“They know there’s money in it,” he said, about the government. “And they want to control it.”

But Mr. Dieng, the government dump manager, insisted that the pickers would either be given jobs at the new sorting centers, “or we help them find a job that will allow them to live better than before.”

That doesn’t reassure everyone.

“There are many changes,” said Maguette Diop, a project officer at WIEGO, a nonprofit organization focused on the working poor worldwide, “and the place of the waste pickers in these changes is not clear.”

For now, though, hundreds of waste pickers have to keep on picking.

Dodging bulldozers, piles of animal guts and cattle, with curved metal spikes and trash bags in their hands, they head back into the fray.

No comments:

Post a Comment